Part 1: Share an Original Post. please refer only to material from our class. This requirement appli ...
Part 1: Share an Original Post. please refer only to material from our class. This requirement applies to all of your assignments. Do not access the Internet or AI to help you draft this work. Please write in complete paragraphs - no bullet points etc. Here are your prompts. Please answer them ALL. The Problem for Sociology is discussed in your course materials. How does this problem manifest in contemporary society? What are some realistic solutions? All lectures are in Modules. From your Lecture on Culture, summarise the key points in "What's a Fair Start".Then, analyse Kate’s response to Mike—what assumptions is she making, and how do they compare with the evidence presented in the class? Provide at least one direct reference to course material to support your evaluation. From your Lecture on Culture: explain how the themes from slides 6,7,8 connect to real-world examples. Provide a specific case or personal insight that illustrates these themes. From your Lecture on Culture, slides: 13, 14, 43, identify two key facts that challenged or changed your understanding of culture. How do these facts compare to what you previously believed or to examples in your own life? The Lottery of Birth is divided into several key parts (the first of which is called BIRTH). Without directly quoting, summarise each part in your own words. Then, select two of these parts and discuss their implications using examples from class discussions, readings, or current events. How does The Lottery of Birth present its argument about patriotism? Critically evaluate whether you agree with its perspective. Use specific references to the material and apply an example from history or current events to support your position.limerick On slide 9 of The Lottery of Birth PowerPoint, click the link and compare five rich, developed nations. Explain what surprised you about the differences presented. What patterns or trends did you notice that align (or don’t align) with your prior knowledge or personal experiences? The Lottery of Birth states: “If we’re lucky, our culture plants the seeds of doubt so that we can develop the tools necessary to question our identity and the world.” In what ways does this align with or challenge your own experiences with culture and identity? Provide a personal reflection or an example from our course material that supports or contradicts this statement Part 2: Respond thoughtfully to 3 classmates' posts. - 1st peer's post (Lor): "1. Sociology often stirs tension in today’s world, as it can lead to all sorts of problems, it creates disagreements between different groups of people from different backgrounds. These challenges arise when different viewpoints clash or are misunderstood. To manage this constructively, it’s essential to foster open dialogue, listen with intention, and seek mutual understanding. Recognizing that a person’s beliefs are just one part of who they are, helps promote empathy. Ultimately, being able to be flexible in the way we think will enable us to accept, understand and respect one another, and will help in building respectful and inclusive relationships across diverse perspectives. 2. The lecture highlighted how cultural values and social structures shape ideas of fairness. It challenged the myth of equal opportunity by showing how race, class, and family background create unequal starting points in life. Just like the lecture mentioned, it explains that some people are born with silver spoons in their mouth, while others are not. And this inequality affects the different individual's potential of success in life. Analysis of Kate’s Response to Mike Kate believes hard work alone leads to success, ignoring the systemic barriers that many people face. This reflects the different cultures in the U.S., which often overlooks inequality. As noted in class and in Lareau’s Unequal Childhoods, middle-class kids benefit from resources and support that working-class children often lack. Kate’s assumption is a common but inaccurate view. The evidence clearly shows that not everyone begins life with the same opportunities, which is essential to understanding social inequality. 3. These slides showed that culture is something we learn and share with others, even if we don’t always notice it. The way we see the world is shaped by the culture we grow up in. I learned from when I was a kid that showing emotions is perceived as a weakness. But this was wrong, because I realized that other cultures—and even different families do not see it that way, and that it’s okay to be open about your feelings. These differences helped me understand that no culture is better or worse than another. They’re just different, and each one has its own way of doing things. 4. I learned that different cultures have their own ways of life. I used to think everyone in a country shared the same culture, but I realized my own immigrant community is a subculture with its own beliefs and tradition. Slide 43 showed how culture can change over time, especially with things like technology and globalization. I used to think culture stayed the same, but now I see how fast it can shift. In my family, older generations keep old traditions, while younger ones mix them with modern ideas from social media. This helped me see that culture isn’t one single thing, but it’s always growing and changing. 5. Birth: This is when we are born in environments and thing we have no control of, such as race, family and religion. This usually is the main determinant of who we are early on in our lives. Culture: Our logics and behavior are learned from the society, they can be learned through media, school, friends, and rules. Society/Freedom: The business and governmental systems at large have power over our lives and the choices we make. Family: Looking at this, one can ask if this word "freedom" actually exists because our live have gotten shaped by all these forces from when we're born. PART TWO: Birth: This explains how the family, race and environment we are born into can affect a person’s chances of success in life. A child born into poverty may not have the same opportunities as one born into a rich family. This shows how much birth can shape our future. Culture: We also learned how things like school and media teach us what’s “normal.” For instance, they shape our views on gender roles or beauty. This proves that many of our beliefs come from what we’ve been taught, not from free choice. 6. The film argues that patriotism is mostly determined by how we’re raised, and can sometimes support harmful beliefs or limit critical thinking. Although all patriotism isn't bad, the film encourages us to find out what influences our values, and to think in a more global and ethical way. By understanding both the risks and benefits of patriotism, we will have a more thoughtful and fair sense of national identity. 7. It surprised me to find out that the U.S. ranked low in healthcare and income equality, even though it's very wealthy. I've always thought that more money would mean better results, but that's not the case here. It's like a pattern that countries like Sweden and Japan, which invest more in public services, had better outcomes and less inequality. Places with bigger income gaps had more problems. After finding out all these information, it changed how I see wealth and success. It showed me that where you're born really affects your chances in life, just like in the film. 8. The quote from The Lottery of Birth—“If we’re lucky, our culture plants the seeds of doubt…” really got me thinking. I grew up just following traditions and not questioning much. For instance, learning about socialization and how our values are shaped by our environment helped me understand that many of my beliefs weren’t really my own, I inherited them. This goes with the film’s idea that only some people get the chance to learn how to question the systems they belong in. So, I agree with the quote. Culture can give us the tools to think critically, but only if it allows room for doubt and open discussion." - 2nd peer's post (Anni): "1. The Problem for Sociology highlights the need to challenge our beliefs and assumptions shaped by our family and culture to understand social issues deeply. This manifests as social inequality in contemporary society, where people face different levels of opportunity based on their background. Realistic solutions include promoting awareness and education that encourages critical thinking, implementing policies that address inequality, and fostering inclusive communities that support diverse perspectives. Another simpler solution could be asking yourself, as mentioned in the module “Why is it so hard to unlearn what we’ve been taught to believe is true?” 2. The “What’s a Fair Start” video breaks down the idea that not everyone has an equitable starting position in their life. The lecture mentions that some of us grow up wealthy and some of us grow up poor. The professor challenges his class and the audience to think about and address how we can look at social, economic, and environmental inequalities to create a fair society. He often mentions how or what we need to do to have everyone succeed in life if we start at uneven playing levels. Kate's response to Mike proves that Kate understands that, based on how she grew up, she was given extra opportunities that most likely helped her get into Harvard. In contrast, Mike explains that he got into Harvard based on his hard work and effort. What he failed to realize, and Kate mentions, is that to have a fair society, we have to understand that some, including herself, get more support or opportunities than others. This idea that Kate presents is similar to slide 67 in the Origins of Sociology, which presents the idea that poor and less privileged people are less likely to be able to develop their talents because of a lack of opportunities. 3. Slides 6,7,8 from the culture lecture show the High/Scope Perry Preschool Study shows how important early education is for better life outcomes. For example, kids who went to quality preschool ended up with lower arrest rates and higher earnings. A good real-world example is how some states are putting more money into preschool programs to help kids from less fortunate backgrounds, so they have a better shot at success later on. It shows how investing in early education can help break the cycle of poverty and give everyone a fair chance. 4. Two key facts from the slides that changed my view on culture are how most OECD countries cut down their poverty rates through redistribution and how COVID made existing inequalities way worse, especially with wealth. I used to think poverty was just about personal choices, but now I see how much impact government policies can have. And the idea that we might be "prisoners of socialization" got me thinking about how our backgrounds shape our views. I’ve noticed this with friends who grew up in different environments and how it affects their perspectives. 5. BIRTH: The video shows how factors like location and socio-economic status can lead to vastly different life opportunities for individuals. FAMILY: It illustrates the impact of family dynamics, showcasing how supportive or challenging family environments can shape a person's character and life choices. SOCIETY: The video emphasizes societal expectations and pressures, demonstrating how they influence individuals’ aspirations and self-perception, often pushing them to conform. CULTURE: Cultural elements are portrayed through various traditions and practices, highlighting how they shape identity and inform the values and behaviors of individuals within different communities. IMPLICATIONS Using family and culture, the video highlights how society shapes our choices through the pressure to conform to expectations, influencing our career paths and personal aspirations, while also showcasing how cultural practices empower individuals and the tension that arises when those values clash with modern norms. 6. The Lottery of Birth argues that blind patriotism can prevent critical thinking about a country’s flaws. It suggests that many view their nation as the best simply because they lack perspective, which can ignore harsh realities and the negative impacts of their country on others. I agree with this view. For instance, during the Vietnam War, many Americans were fiercely patriotic and overlooked the suffering caused to the Vietnamese people. This disconnect highlights how unchecked patriotism can hinder awareness and meaningful discussions about a nation’s actions. Looking through a sociological lens is essential. 7. In comparing the five rich nations, I was surprised by the differences in unemployment and resource usage. The U.S. has an 11.29% higher chance of being unemployed than Canada, which is unfortunate. France uses almost 60% less oil than Canada, which is good because it indicates a more sustainable energy approach and a lower carbon footprint. Germany's unemployment rate is 50% lower than France's, reflecting a stronger economy and better job security. However, it's crazy that Australians are almost 90% more likely to be arrested than Germans, highlighting significant differences in law enforcement and social issues between the two countries. 8. The idea from "The Lottery of Birth" really resonates with my own experiences because I’ve often found myself questioning my identity and the cultural norms around me. I used to identify myself sometimes as just one certain thing, like being part of a specific group or having a certain label, but I realized I am so much more than that. Reflecting on my journey, I see how embracing my multifaceted identity has allowed me to grow, challenge stereotypes, and appreciate the diverse influences that shape who I am today." - 3rd peer's post (Ang): "1. The Problem for Sociology A major challenge that sociology faces stems from the fact that people generally fail to recognize the significant influence of their surroundings on their thoughts. Our cultural environment teaches us all our internalized ideas and values because we usually mistake them as belonging to ourselves alone. Modern society shows itself in the way people assess others, even though they lack knowledge about their circumstances and troubles. A helpful solution involves creating awareness by teaching people and holding direct conversations that we practice in our current classroom. 2. Kate’s video “What’s a Fair Start” Presents Her View “What’s a Fair Start” presents evidence that people begin their lives with different available chances. Kate remains convinced that hard work gives everyone equal opportunities in life, despite all available evidence showing otherwise. According to our lecture on culture, starting chances depend on factors such as race, gender, and class right from the outset (Slide 13). The environment of individuals receives little attention from Kate when evaluating their chances at success. 3. Slides 6, 7, 8, and Real-Life Connections The information presented in slides 6 to 8 demonstrated that culture exists through shared knowledge, yet learning this information is typically difficult to notice. The way we observe the world derives from culture. In my childhood, I had learned that emotional openness equated to weakness. People learn opposing lessons about openness in different cultures as well as within different family environments. Cultural differences motivated me to understand that alternate ways of life should not be considered superior or inferior since they simply exist as distinct phenomena 4. Two Surprising Facts from Slides 13, 14, 43 People seem to consider their cultural background as the standard norm, according to Slide 14. I used to think that, too. The third interesting point comes from Slide 43, which describes the importance of challenging beliefs. An initial fear that questioning things made me seem challenging now teaches me to value questions as valuable assets. The impact of this experience made me develop a greater understanding of different cultures. 5. The Lottery of Birth: Summary and Analysis The sections of The Lottery of Birth documentary are arranged into BIRTH, FAMILY, SOCIETY, and CULTURE. The different segments create a case for the argument that numerous life elements are established before people can influence them. This section of BIRTH illustrates how birthplace and time of birth create massive differences in our available opportunities. In the FAMILY segment it reveals how both family resources and parent expectations together with parenting methods determine future life directions. The documentary separates information into distinct parts which directly support classroom discussions about social determinism and mobility. Early advantages in life accumulate throughout time according to the video which directly matches the concepts presented in our social class lecture.. 6. Patriotism in the Film The film depicts patriotism as an obstruction that prevents people from detecting issues within their homeland. I agree with this. When you love your nation truly, you wish for its growth even if it requires expressing what needs improvement. Those classified as unpatriotic by society ended up strengthening the United States because of their actions, such as Martin Luther King Jr. 7. Five-Nation Comparison The results of comparing five wealthy nations displayed that money fails to guarantee successful outcomes. The United States delivered inferior health and education outcomes in comparison to Norway because of its weaker supportive framework. This experience caused me to doubt the notion America held as "the best" country. The incarceration numbers and inequality metrics in wealthy nations turned out to be substantially lower than the United States statistics. The two nations demonstrate reduced prisoner populations while maintaining robust welfare system programs. The governments with elevated tax rates managed to generate better achievements for education and health results. The observed patterns disproved my existing belief that diminished tax rates and self-reliance generate superior system performance. The experience led me to doubt if American values line up with true national wellness metrics. 8. Seeds of Doubt The concept about how doubt leads to personal development appealed strongly to me. Before starting this course, I rarely concentrated on the cultural influences that have formed me. I am studying to both observe my thoughts and to query vital questions more profoundly. The personal growth experience paved the way for improvement in my student life, along with my character development. The Lottery of Birth effectively states that cultural influences generate doubtful thoughts. I relate to this deeply. Success and gender expectations along with personal identity beliefs were imposed on me during my upbringing. Education together with encounters with diverse perspectives helped me develop doubts about beliefs which I had learned as a child. Doing this course revealed that asking questions never amounts to betrayal because the process leads us to improved personal development. During our social norms discussion I understood that numerous unspoken cultural guidelines were driving my actions while I was unknowingly unconcerned about them. The realization has led me to make conscious efforts about my life practices." MATERIALS Are Attached below. Please check them out to work on this assignment. From The Lottery Of Birth: Here's the Tri-Lateral Commission (Search "rising expectations"): https://archive.org/stream/TheCrisisOfDemocracy-Tr... VIDEO: The Lottery of Birth (2013). Do you shape the world or does it shape you?: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1hPPSa3cU56u4AHZwK...
