Forward Mapping Map forward from the T.V.P.A. to an actual reduction of trafficking in Thailand, relative to what would have prevailed in the absence of the U.S. Legislation (using something like the table below). Forward mapping concerns policy implementation, and is a tool used to work through specific chains of actions and behaviors that will trace the link from the U.S. T.V.P.A. policy to an actual reduction in trafficking in Thailand . Question that must be answered Write a narrative that describe all the behaviors that must be realized for the policy to produce desired outcomes. Be specific about who, what, when and why. Hint: The narrative is (reducing sex trafficking) Is the scenario plausible? For each actor mentioned: 1. Is the hypothesized behavior consistent with personal and organizational interests? 2. If not, what tactics could actors use to avoid complying? 3. What counter tactics could be used to force or induce compliance? Thinking of the direct and indirect effects of the policy, what other actors would have an incentive to become involved? For each of these actors. 1. How could the actors interfere with the hypothesized behaviors? 2. What tactics could be used to block or deflect interference? Revise the narrative to make it more plausible?
Related to the United States and Thailand readings answer the following 2 questions: Why is there so much trafficking in Thailand? Who are the relevant stakeholders? There are 7 stakeholders For each actor, include the stakeholder's motivations concerning the policy, beliefs regarding the policy, and available resources as related to any aspect of the policy and its implementation
What constitutes an appropriate role for the judiciary? Some people argue that courts have become too powerful and that judges legislate from the bench. What does it mean for a court to be activist? What does it mean for a court to show judicial restraint? Although conservatives have long complained about the activism of liberal justices and judges, in recent years liberals have pointed out that conservative judges and justices are now more likely to overturn precedents and question the power of elected institutions of government. Conservatives counter by saying they are simply returning to an older precedent that had been ignored by liberals. If both liberals and conservatives engage in judicial activism, what is the role of the concept of “activism” (perhaps judicial activism is just a term used to describe a court decision you disagree with)?
The long-term solvency of Social Security is widely believed to be in danger. Play the American Academy of Actuaries Social Security GameLinks to an external site.. Once you have "solved" the game. Share your select results with your classmates by discussing the following questions: What options you found to be off limits, and why? What options did you select to solve the social security problem? Explain your choices. Note: When replying to your peers on their post for the "Social Security" activity - comment and ask questions about their choiceshttps://socialsecurity.actuary.org/
As part of a policy memo for the mayor and St. Paul city council, 1) include a stakeholder analysis as detailed as possible for the "Community-First Public Safety" case study, and 2) answer Leonard's three questions for the proposed community-first public safety program as best you can based on the available material/information. Create a stakeholder Analysis for Community- First Public Safety this includes the process of identifying these people before the project starts, grouping them according to their level of participation, interest and influences in the project. Determining how best to involve and communicate each of the stakeholders groups throughout. Example: So interest, influences work the needs, concerns, and expectations *DONT FORGET THESE QUESTION MUST ALSO BE INICLUDED INTHE ANALYSIS* These 3 question must be answered in the stake analysis 1. Do we have the capacity to carry out this program based on money, people, skills, authority space and knowledge ? 2. Do we have the support of the people or organizations whose support ( or opposition) to this program is relevant to our carrying if we move forward ? Meaning will the program be supported by the constituencies whos support is relevant. 3. Would the operation of this action , program, initiative create (net) public values. This question calls for judgement -indeed value- based, moral judgement.
Review Weiner & Vining, particularly on backward mapping. As part of a policy memo for the mayor and St. Paul city council, 1) include a stakeholder analysis as detailed as possible for the "Community-First Public Safety" case study, and 2) answer Leonard's three questions for the proposed community-first public safety program as best you can based on the available material/information. Question 1: Do we have the capacity to carry out this program? Question 2: Do we have the support of the people or organizations whose support (or opposition) to this program is relevant to our carrying it forward? Question 3: Would the operation of this action, program, or initiative create (net) public value?
Considering the "Community-First Public Safety" case study, and the articles on different ways of approaching policy analysis, in a second policy memo for the mayor, first discuss what problem the several programs/components (Reimagining Public Safety in Saint Paul) are addressing (be as specific as possible in defining the problem-and is it the same for the various stakeholders?). Provide a brief overview of each program components. For the three most important components in terms of the Mayor's overall vision, forward map the policy components as best you can. Provide all this information in a detailed policy memo.
Stone and Forester address policy analysis and how one might think about analysis and decision-making from a different angle/perspective than the more traditional policy approach. Using the following example, discuss how incorporating Stone and/or Forester's ideas could make for a better analysis of how to renovate a "seedy" downtown. In particular, think about the types of questions you might first need to ask and consider based on Stone and Forester, including why I should consider a different word than "seedy"?