Description ~~ "In Art" & "After Art" ~~ For our last module we compared the differences between "closed" and "open" systems of evil: A -- we aimed to seek out and to understand these opposed "systems" as representations in art / in entertainment, namely in our films Chaos and Open Water... B -- and we also aimed to understand these opposed "systems" as systems that can potentially come after art as the social effect of art, and this was effectively for us to understand these opposed systems in connection with questions about "the social responsibility of the artist," specifically the social responsibility of the creative makers of the films Chaos and Open Water. The questions which I coaxed us to either explicitly or implicitly asked were: * What is the nature of the evil in the films Chaos and Open Water? * Is the evil that is artistically represented in these films a "closed" or "open" system? * What makes one kind of evil a "closed system"? What makes another kind of evil an "open system"? * What is the effect on audiences of a "closed system" of evil? What is the effect on audiences of an "open system" of evil? * Why do the above question matter anyway? Why are such questions about the representation of evil in art / entertainment socially relevant? ~~ Shakespeare's "Open System" of Evil ~~ In our assigned article from Module 1 -- "Evil in Film: To What End?" -- Roger Ebert characterizes "a closed system" of evil as an evil in art / entertainment "in which any alternative outcome" -- namely the outcomes of "good" and / or "redemption" -- "is excluded." And Ebert indeed means "alternative outcomes" to evil (whether energies of goodness or redemption) that are either explicitly "excluded" or implicitly "excluded," for because the ways in which the possibilities of goodness or redemption are excluded are not always obvious. Ebert then goes on to say: "it is like a movie of a man falling to his death, which can have no developments except that he continues to fall, and no ending except that he dies." We will assume that with his art Shakespeare communicates an "open system" of evil on virtue that we audiences remain always aware -- and oftentimes (but not always) the villain remains aware -- that an "alternative outcome" or an "alternative possibility" --- namely, the choice to choose the very opposite of evil -- remains not only a possibility but also an actuality...since, in Shakespeare's art, the energies of goodness are actualized in characters side-by-side with the energies of evil that are actualized in the villains. In other words, what remains available to the sympathies of the audiences of Shakespeare's plays (in this case, we ourselves are Shakespeare's audience) are the energies of "good" characters who -- more than the evil characters -- make a direct appeal to our sympathies and our sensibilities-- precisely in the same instance in which we are engaging cruel, barbaric (i.e., evil) characters. In a Shakespearean universe, there exists, side-by-side with the energies of evil, enough of the energies of goodness as to leave us with the impression that it will not be the energies of evil but the energies of "the good" that will finally triumph in such a universe-- whether in art or after art. What makes the film Chaos a "closed system" of evil according to Ebert's account, is not so much that evil is depicted as attractive, as worthy of our sympathies, but rather that there exists no "alternative outcome" of redemption or goodness available to audiences to find attractive, or with which to sympathize. The effect upon audiences after art as the total effect of art, consequently, might become the feeling or the experience of hopelessness, nihilism in audiences: the sense that what finally acquires supremacy in the world is a kind of animal -- dog-eat-dog -- cruelty in humans, according to Ebert's account. What makes Shakespeare's plays Othello, Macbeth, and Richard III more of an "open system" of evil is the reality that reality itself is a cosmic drama, a drama in which the energies of good and evil are depicted in converse-ation (or at war) with each other, and in which the latter energy (evil) is unambiguously depicted as an energy to be avoided, as an energy to be eschewed, as an energy for the human not to emulate. Or to offer one other reason why Shakespeare's theatrical fictions are an "open" and not a "closed" system of evil, borrowing here Ebert's words... [Ebert] while "art can certainly be nihilistic and express hopelessness" and while "evil can indeed win in [the] fiction[s]" of film and literature, "as it often does in real life," by contrast, with an "open system" of evil, to again borrow Ebert's definition, "the artist express[es] an attitude toward that evil," because, "it is not enough to [just simply] record it." In short, with an "open system" of evil as represented in art, we are never not sure what the artist "think[s] and feel [s] about" the given species of evil being represented in his/her art. For reasons that are not always explicit but typically only "intuited," we audiences are never not sure of Shakespeare's attitude towards the evil that he represents, and that certainty, and that surety, puts Shakespeare's system of evil in the category of an "open system" of evil, in which the possibility of "goodness" remain always a universal possibility, even if in the universes of Shakespeare's art such possibilities are not necessarily selected. "Drama" -- understood as the Eternal "Conflict Between Good and Evil" What makes Shakespeare's systems of evil "open" and not "closed" systems of evil is that they are basically and fundamentally, in a word, dramatic. But we must elaborate on the word drama by saying that "drama" or the "dramatic mode" themselves were to Shakespeare -- as to the ancient Greek and Roman playwrights and philosophers -- synonymous with what is known as the eternal conflict between good and evil. Or, in short: drama ultimately IS the eternal conflict between good and evil. What doesn't evince the eternal conflict between good and evil is not drama, in the classical sense. There are several variations of drama understood as the eternal conflict between good and evil -- 1. one being the battle between individuals or ideologies, with one side held up as Good, while the other is portrayed as Evil. 2. another variation is the inner struggle in characters (and by extension, humans in reality) between good and evil; in other words we detect an inner conflict between good and evil either (1) in the identity of a character or (2) in the identity of a community, or historical situation or place. A corollary to the (above) second mode of drama understood as the eternal conflict between good and evil is the conflict between the inner good and the inner flawed aspects of a character or community. And it is this variety of evil that predominates in Shakespearean systems of evil, in which good and evil are depicted as warring themselves out either (1) in the identity of a character; or (2) in the identity of a community, or a historical situation of a place. And with this variety of evil, evil wars itself out in such a way that we can identify either (1) the identity of the character or (2) the identity of a historical situation of a place as evil precisely because we can identify -- or we can feel -- in the character or in the place the waning absence, the gradual short-circuiting of an inner or intrinsic goodness...or redemption. And sometimes -- as in the case of Shakespeare's Richard III -- we may even identity or feel the total eclipse of the energies of goodness or redemption in identity of the character while at the time feeling that these positive energies hold on strong in the identity of a place and its people. We may now infer that while "open systems" -- insofar as they contain (however ambiguously) both good and evil in conversation (or at war) with each other -- are fundamentally dramatic. And by contrast, "closed systems" of evil -- insofar as they amplify evil (and / or even celebrate it) and insofar as they occlude (and /or downgrade or even satirize) "the good" -- these systems are fundamentally non-dramatic, as is implied in Ebert's claim that with "closed systems evil" only one thing (evil) eternally happens, and not a tensional exchange of two things, good and evil -- "a man falling [eternally] to his death, which can have no developments except that he continues to fall, and no ending...no alternative outcome... except that he dies." In any case, Shakespearean evil constitutes an open system of evil in a variety of ways, but still underlying each variety is something common, namely the eternal conflict between good and evil understood precisely as that: eternal, by which I mean that it's a conflict that, to Shakespeare's understanding, is not going to go away anytime soon. Drama: the Varieties of the Eternal Conflict of Good and Evil in Othello, Macbeth, Richard III As part of our module assignment I assign a short 3-part (very low-budget) video documentary by the renowned (and very eccentric) Shakespearean scholar Steven Berkoff. In it, Berkoff performs the following characterizations (shades, types, varieties) of evil, and I will return to them throughout the semester so please keep them in mind : - first he gives ("performs") a simple text-book definition of a evil in a villain: "it is a person purely motivated by their own lusts, desires and greed, irrespective of the pain they may cause you, or even inspired by the pain they may cause you." - second Berkoff goes on to conjecture that evil is sometimes caused by bad upbringing, by the absence of an exposure to love in "early life".. "[Villans are] who may have had very little love in their early life, and therefore they have no pattern, no way of expressing love, because...love is a uniquely human thing...it's got to be learned...and [a villain] is like an undernourished tree that can only give off bad fruit... the milk of human kindness does not run through the villains veins...the milkman didn't leave it there that day. - third Berkoff "performs" uniquely different categories or varieties of villains, villains of different "types" or "shades"... but in his short mini-documentary, he emphasizes mainly three: "mediocre" villains and "genius" villains and "witty" villains...and for this module we will only focus on these three... But later in the semester we may pick up on some of the other villains he highlights, so do keep them in mind... "You've got brilliant villains, witty villains, idiot villains, Machiavellian villains and mediocre villains...and Iago [in Othello] is a mediocre villain.." - fourth Berkoff "performs" the very opposite of villainy / evil: he calls it "Love"... "...to love you have to be open, vulnerable and naked...and of course a villain is armored, tight, frightened, hiding behind a wall of fear, from which he occassionally peeps out..." - fifth, in part 3 of his documentary, Berkoff, discusses the urgency of having to perform Shakespeare's pre-modern stagings of the drama evil in "original ways," so that modern audiences can access pre-modern literature; but -- very importantly -- he implies that this act of making a pre-modern literature accessible to modern audiences is only possible because something about the deep inner essence of certain of Shakespeare's plots is eternal, namely the conflict between good and evil, which, in Berkoff's account, is eternal: by which he means that, via the best presentations of such evil plots, the drama of evil becomes palpable and potent to any audience from any time (epoch) or from any place (geographical location)... "you have to try to play Shakespeare 'modern'...you might play it 'science fiction,' you can play it 'nude,' you can play it 'gay,' but you have to find an original way of capturing the imagination of the audience...because the imagination of the audience, if you like, is like a great whale... and you are like the character in 'Moby Dick,' pulling in the great whale that is the audiences imagination...you have got to harness is somehow...and many many actors have tried...you have to find a different [always a modern, always new, contemporary] way of doing it [of capturing the whale that is imagination of the audience.." Richard III (1995): A Modern Film Drama of Evil Modernized for Modern Audiences In the film version of Shakespeare's play Richard III, Ian McKellen plays the evil king Richard III as a Neo-Nazi. And while Shakespeare had no experience with Nazi-ism, it was the aim of the director of the film to communicate that (1) something about the drama of evil playing out in a modern Neo-Nazi (from the film) and (2) something about the drama of evil playing out in a pre-modern, Medieval king (from Shakespeare's original play) makes us feel that both forms of the drama of evil are essentially the same form but placed in different appearances / contexts. In other words, to the film's director, it is essentially the same metaphysical form of the drama of evil playing out in two very different physical times and places in essentially the same way. Which is to say that, to the director of the film, the drama that is "the conflict of good and evil" is eternal and metaphysical; but what's different is the physical presentation -- or re-presentation -- of it. Berkoff, on the universality and eternality of evil, comments: "...[The modern Richard III] is a brilliant conception, which shows, which proves the universality of Shakespeare [in this case Shakespeare's representation of the drama of evil]...that you can set it in the 1930s, as a Nazi, and the lines, the ideas would fit, because the inner psychology is virtually the same [as it was in Shakespeare's original presentation of an evil king]..." *** For this module we will explore varieties -- i.e., various re-presentations -- of the universality and eternality of the drama of good and evil in several of Shakespeare's plays, and I ask that we keep this in mind: that insofar we speak of a "drama" or of a "dramatic" form of evil, we are always speaking of an "open system" of evil on virtue that -- whether explicitly or implicitly -- there is always two things (good and evil) being represented, and not just one thing: evil. Study Materials: - "Shakespeare's Villains," Steven Berkoff, Parts 1 - 3 - Shakespeare, Othello, Macbeth, Richard III Part 1: Students will perform the following assignment: "Mediocre Evil" In his mini-documentary -- a kind of master-class -- on the "varieties of evil" in Shakespeare's plays, Berkoff characterizes the evil of the character of Iago in Shakespeare's Othello as "mediocre." Relying on Berkoff's reasons for why the species of evil that Iago expresses is "mediocre," (1) seek out and (2) cite / quote and (3) explain a few examples of Iago's "mediocre" evil from either the Othello text (which I provided in our MODULE STUDY MATERIALS section) or from one of the video performances which you may readily find on the internet. (appx. 250 words) Part 2: Students will perform the following assignment: "Genius Evil" In his mini-documentary -- a kind of master-class -- on the "varieties of evil" in Shakespeare's plays, Berkoff characterizes the evil of the character of Richard III in Shakespeare's play as "genius." Relying on Berkoff's reasons for why the species of evil that Richard III expresses is "genius," (1) seek out and (2) cite / quote and (3) explain a few examples of Richard III's evil from either the Richard III text (which I provided in our MODULE STUDY MATERIALS section) or from one of the video performances which you may readily find on the internet. And you may indeed use the 1995 modern film version of Richard III that I refer to in our Module 2 lecture. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Py9CMN3TYyM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9ae2B5h628 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdLXqqnREX4
READ MORE >>