Need Help ?

Home / Expert Answers / Other /   ASSIGNMENT - Legal Case 2   University and Community College System of Nevada v. Farmer  

  ASSIGNMENT - Legal Case 2   University and Community College System of Nevada v. Farmer   ...


  ASSIGNMENT - Legal Case 2   University and Community College System of Nevada v. Farmer   Re-read the University case, "University and Community College System of Nevada v. Farmer in your textbook. Note the data under the case title: 113 Nev. 90, 930 P.2d 730 (Nev. Sup. Ct. 1997), cert. denied, 523 U.S. 1004 (March 9, 1998). What do these details signify? Study the case questions in the text at the end of the case. In addition, look through other material provided in Lecture Notes and in the Preface. Outline and submit the case, using the standard legal outline headings. (See "Sample Outline for Legal Cases" in Course Materials.)   OUTLINE THAT MUST BE FOLLOWED FOR ASSIGNMENT: Case Name and Citation Include the court or agency deciding the case Include the citation, which tells where to find the reported decision. Key Facts (in brief) Why - are parties before the court or agency? What - are the parties seeking? Stage in the legal process (Trial Court, NLRB,Appeals Court, etc.) What happened at prior stages (if any) in the legal process? Legal Issue (s) Include legal problem(s) raised by the facts of the dispute. Reasoning of the Decision-Maker Why was dispute resolved the way it was? How did the decision-maker apply or reconcile the legal principles involved? READING ARTICLE FOR OUTLINE:   Between 1989 and 1991, only one percent of the University   of Nevada’s full-time faculty were black, while eightyseven   to eighty-nine percent of the full-time faculty were   white; twenty-five to twenty-seven percent of the full-time   faculty were women. In order to remedy this racial imbalance,   the University instituted the “minority bonus   policy,” an unwritten amendment to its affirmative action   policy that allowed a department to hire an additional faculty   member following the initial placement of a minority   candidate.   In 1990, the University advertised for an impending   vacancy in the sociology department. The announcement   of the position vacancy emphasized a need for proficiency   in social psychology and mentioned a salary range between   $28,000.00 and $34,000.00, dependent upon experience   and qualifications. The University’s hiring guidelines   require departments to conduct more than one interview;   however, this procedure may be waived in certain cases.   Yvette Farmer was one of the three finalists chosen by the   search committee for the position but the University   obtained a waiver to interview only one candidate, Johnson   Makoba, a black African male. The department chair   recalled that the search committee ranked Makoba first   among the three finalists. Because of a perceived shortage   of black Ph.D. candidates, coupled with Makoba’s strong   academic achievements, the search committee sought   approval to make a job offer to Makoba at a salary of   $35,000.00, with an increase to $40,000.00 upon completing   his Ph.D. This initial offer exceeded the advertised salary   range for the position; even though Makoba had not   accepted any competing offers, the University justified its   offer as a method of preempting any other institutions from   hiring Makoba. Makoba accepted the job offer. Farmer was   subsequently hired by the University the following year;   the position for which she was hired was created under   the “minority bonus policy.” Her salary was set at   $31,000.00 and a $2,000.00 raise after completion of her   dissertation.   Farmer sued the University and Community College   System of Nevada (“the University”) claiming violations   of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the Equal Pay Act   and for breach of an employment contract. Farmer alleged   that despite the fact that she was more qualified, the University   hired a black male (Makoba) as an assistant professor   of sociology instead of her because of the University’s   affirmative action plan. After a trial on her claims, the trial   court jury awarded her $40,000 in damages, and the University   appealed to the Supreme Court of Nevada. The   issue on appeal was the legality of the University’s affirmative   action plan under both Title VII and the U.S.   Constitution.   Steffen, Chief Justice   … Farmer claims that she was more qualified for the position   initially offered to Makoba. However, the curriculum   vitae for both candidates revealed comparable strengths   with respect to their educational backgrounds, publishing,   areas of specialization, and teaching experience. The search   committee concluded that despite some inequalities, their   strengths and weaknesses complemented each other; hence,   as a result of the additional position created by the minority   bonus policy, the department hired Farmer one year   later.…   The University contends that the district court made a   substantial error of law by failing to enter a proposed jury   instruction which would have apprised the jury that Title   VII does not proscribe race-based affirmative action   144 Part 2 » Equal Employment Opportunity   programs designed to remedy the effects of past discrimination   against traditionally disadvantaged classes. The University   asserts that the district court’s rejection of the proposed   instruction left the jury with the impression that all racebased   affirmative action programs are proscribed.…   Farmer … asserts that the University’s unwritten minority   bonus policy contravenes its published affirmative action plan.   Finally, Farmer alleges that all race-based affirmative action   plans are proscribed under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act   as amended in 1991; therefore, the University discriminated   against her as a female, a protected class under Title VII.   Tension exists between the goals of affirmative action   and Title VII’s proscription against employment practices   which are motivated by considerations of race, religion,   sex, or national origin, because Congress failed to provide   a statutory exception for affirmative action under Title VII.   Until recently, the Supreme Court’s failure to achieve a   majority opinion in affirmative action cases has produced   schizophrenic results.…   United Steelworkers of America v. Weber is the seminal   case defining permissible voluntary affirmative action plans   [under Title VII].… Under Weber, a permissible voluntary   affirmative action plan must: (1) further Title VII’s statutory   purpose by “break[ing] down old patterns of racial segregation   and hierarchy” in “occupations which have been   traditionally closed to them”; (2) not “unnecessarily trammel   the interests of white employees”; (3) be “a temporary   measure; it is not intended to maintain racial balance, but   simply to eliminate a manifest racial imbalance.” …   Most recently, in Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Pena, the   Supreme Court revisited [the issue of the constitutionality   of] affirmative action in the context of a minority set-aside   program in federal highway construction. In the 5–4 opinion,   the Court held that a reviewing court must apply strict   scrutiny analysis for all race-based affirmative action programs,   whether enacted by a federal, state, or local   entity.… [T]he Court explicitly stated “that federal racial   classifications, like those of a State, must serve a compelling   governmental interest, and must be narrowly tailored to   further that interest.” …   Here, in addition to considerations of race, the University   based its employment decision on such criteria as educational   background, publishing, teaching experience, and   areas of specialization. This satisfies [the previous cases’]   commands that race must be only one of several factors   used in evaluating applicants. We also view the desirability   of a racially diverse faculty as sufficiently analogous to the   constitutionally permissible attainment of a racially diverse   student body.…   The University’s affirmative action plan conforms to   the Weber factors [under Title VII]. The University’s   attempts to diversify its faculty by opening up positions traditionally   closed to minorities satisfies the first factor under   Weber. Second, the plan does not “unnecessarily trammel the   interests of white employees.” The University’s 1992 Affirmative   Action Report revealed that whites held eighty-seven to   eighty-nine percent of the full-time faculty positions. Finally,   with blacks occupying only one percent of the faculty positions,   it is clear that through its minority bonus policy, the   University attempted to attain, as opposed to maintain, a racial   balance.   The University’s affirmative action plan … [also] passes   constitutional muster. The University demonstrated that it   has a compelling interest in fostering a culturally and ethnically   diverse faculty. A failure to attract minority faculty   perpetuates the University’s white enclave and further limits   student exposure to multicultural diversity. Moreover, the   minority bonus policy is narrowly tailored to accelerate   racial and gender diversity. Through its affirmative action   policies, the University achieved greater racial and gender   diversity by hiring Makoba and Farmer. Of note is the   fact that Farmer’s position is a direct result of the minority   bonus policy.   Although Farmer contends that she was more qualified   for Makoba’s position, the search committee determined   that Makoba’s qualifications slightly exceeded Farmer’s.   The record, however, reveals that both candidates were   equal in most respects. Therefore, given the aspect of   subjectivity involved in choosing between candidates,   the University must be given the latitude to make its   own employment decisions provided that they are not   discriminatory.   [The court then rejected Farmer’s claim that the 1991   amendments to Title VII prohibit affirmative action.]   … we conclude that the jury was not equipped to   understand the necessary legal basis upon which it could   reach its factual conclusions concerning the legality of the   University’s affirmative action plan. Moreover, the undisputed   facts of this case warranted judgment in favor of   the University as a matter of law. Therefore, even if the   jury had been properly instructed, the district court should   have granted the University’s motion for judgment notwithstanding   the [jury’s] verdict. Reversal of the jury’s verdict   on the Title VII claim is therefore in order.   The University … has adopted a lawful race-conscious   affirmative action policy in order to remedy the effects of a   manifest racial imbalance in a traditionally segregated job   category.…   Chapter 6 » Title VII of the Civi l Rights Act and Race Discr imination 145   The affirmative action plan in the previous case was a voluntary plan; that is, it was not   imposed upon the employer by a court to remedy a finding of illegal discrimination. The   affirmative action plans in the Weber, Johnson, and Wygant cases were also voluntary   plans. Title VII specifically mentions affirmative action as a possible remedy available under   §706(g)(1). In Local 28, Sheet Metal Workers Int. Ass’n. v. EEOC,26 the Supreme Court held   that Title VII permits a court to require the adoption of an affirmative action program to   remedy “persistent or egregious discrimination.” The Court in U.S. v. Paradise27 upheld the   constitutionality of a judicially imposed affirmative action program to remedy race discrimination   in promotion decisions by the Alabama State Police.   ethical DILEMMA   You are the human resource manager for Wydget Corporation, a small manufacturing   company. Wydget’s assembly plant is located in an inner-city neighborhood,   and most of its production employees are African Americans and Hispanics, as well as   some Vietnamese and Laotians who live nearby. Wydget’s managers are white males   who sometimes have difficulty relating to the production workers. The board of directors   of Wydget is considering whether to establish a training program to groom production   workers for management positions, targeting women and minorities in particular. The   CEO has asked you to prepare a memo to guide the board of directors in its decision   about the training program. Should you establish such a program? How can you   encourage minority employees to enter the program without discouraging the white   employees? What criteria should be used for determining admission into the training   program? Address these issues in a short memo, explaining and supporting your   position.   The University has aggressively sought to achieve more   than employment neutrality by encouraging its departments   to hire qualified minorities, women, veterans, and handicapped   individuals. The minority bonus policy, albeit an   unwritten one, is merely a tool for achieving cultural diversity   and furthering the substantive goals of affirmative action.   For the reasons discussed above, the University’s affirmative   action policies pass constitutional muster. Farmer   has failed to raise any material facts or law which would   render the University’s affirmative action policy constitutionally   infirm.…   Young and Rose, JJ., concur.   Springer, J., dissenting [omitted]    



Radioactive Tutors

Radio Active Tutors is a freelance academic writing assistance company. We provide our assistance to the numerous clients looking for a professional writing service.

NEED A CUSTOMIZE PAPER ON THE ABOVE DETAILS?
Order Now


OR

Get outline(Guide) for this assignment at only $10

Get Outline $10

**Outline takes 30 min - 2 hrs depending on the complexity and size of the task
Designed and developed by Brian Mubichi (mubix)
WhatsApp